When 130 banks worth $47 trillion dollars decide to stop investing in carbon-generating capitalism...it's good news

Look at what a plaited and focussed young woman, and consistent activism on the streets, can start to achieve… We noticed this initiative, reported by Matthew Green at Reuters, that “banks worth $47 trillion dollar have adopted new UN backed climate principles”:

Deutsche Bank, Citigroup and Barclays were among 130 banks to join the new framework on the eve of a United Nations summit in New York aimed at pushing companies and governments to act quickly to avert catastrophic global warming. 

“These principles mean banks have to consider the impact of their loans on society – not just on their portfolio,” Simone Dettling, banking team lead for the Geneva-based United Nations Environment Finance Initiative, told Reuters. 

Under pressure from investors, regulators and climate activists, some big banks have acknowledged the role lenders will need to play in a rapid transition to a low-carbon economy. 

Financing for oil, gas and coal projects has come under particular scrutiny as climate scientists step up calls to change the global economy’s deep reliance on fossil-fuels to avert disastrous warming. 

The principles, drawn up jointly by U.N. officials and banks, require lenders to: 

  • Align their strategies with the 2015 Paris Agreement to curb global warming and U.N.-backed targets to fight poverty called the Sustainable Development Goals 

  • Set targets to increase “positive impacts” and reduce “negative impacts” on people and the environment 

  • Work with clients and customers to encourage sustainable practices 

  • Be transparent and accountable about their progress. 

The principles’ main backers say the norms will encourage banks to pivot their loan portfolios away from carbon-intensive assets and redirect capital to greener industries. 

Critics argue that banks should go much further by explicitly committing to phasing out financing for fossil fuel projects and agribusiness that drive deforestation in the Amazon, Southeast Asia and other regions. 

However, the new standards could also force participating banks to choose between foregoing business from clients in high-carbon sectors and the risk of being accused of backsliding on the principles if they continue to finance such firms. 

Although the initiative is voluntary, Dettling, who played a central role during 18 months of negotiations with a core group of 30 founding banks, said lenders would be reluctant to accept the reputational risk of losing their signatory status. 

“They need to demonstrate that they are making progress — and progress within a given timeline,” Dettling said. 

“Ultimately, banks that are not in line with their commitments and do not make progress can be stripped of their signatory status,” she said. 

Banks in Europe, in particular, also face growing regulatory pressure to disclose their exposure to the potential impact of climate-related disasters and a low-carbon energy transition on their asset base. 

Bank of England Governor Mark Carney, who has joined counterparts in France and the Netherlands to push for better supervision of climate risk, was due to address the U.N. climate summit on Monday, according to a draft agenda [see Carney’s Channel Four interview from July].

Other banks to join the “Principles for Responsible Banking” initiative included Danske Bank, ABN Amro, BNP Paribas, Commerzbank, Lloyds Banking Group and Societe Generale, according to a statement.

In his podcast a few weeks ago, the academic macro-economist Mark Blyth noted this initiative and explained it simply as a move towards more secure returns - “if many of your assets are tied up in property based in coastal areas like Florida, where if it’s flooded three times the asset value collapses, then you want to start supporting viable alternative models, or you lose your shirt”.

One bank visibly not in this initiative is Goldman Sachs - whom the Intercept’s Kate Aronoff (author of the forthcoming A Planet to Win: Why We Need A Green New Deal) neatly skewers below, as they greenwash:

So, a complex, compromised scene. But still promising, if the major flows of capital in the world can get behind the investments and infra-structural programmes necessary. All hands on deck.